Good Company, Expensive Shares: What Good News Means for Investors
Budgeting & Saving [email protected] (Robin Powell) 870 reads
Good news can lift a share price before you buy. Compare what your money buys now with what it bought before the announcement.

A company can improve its prospects and still be a poor buy at the price investors are being asked to pay. That distinction is easy to miss when a promising announcement dominates the conversation. Evidence from surveys in Britain, the US and Germany suggests many investors focus on whether a business is getting better, while overlooking how much the share price has already risen.
The difference matters most when news has been public for weeks. By then, other investors may have acted on it, pushing up the price. A later buyer gets a smaller ownership stake for the same amount of money, so the improved outlook needs to justify that higher cost.
Good news and a good investment are different questions
Researchers from the universities of Bonn, Cologne and Frankfurt tested this idea with a scenario about a global sportswear brand. The company had agreed to work with a new supplier in a deal expected to reduce raw material costs by a fifth. Four weeks later, participants were asked whether its shares would perform better over the next year than if it had kept its previous supplier.
Among British adults who took part, 82% expected the shares to do better. About three in four private investors surveyed in the US and Germany shared that expectation, as did 58% of fund managers at two large German fund groups. People who answered three standard financial literacy questions correctly were more likely to predict better share performance.
Most finance academics in the researchers’ survey reached a different conclusion: two thirds thought the announcement would make no difference to returns. Their reasoning turns on the price. A deal that raises expected profits may also prompt investors to bid up the shares, leaving new buyers to pay more for those profits.
In the British survey, people’s explanations largely centred on the company’s prospects. Only 7% referred to its share price. That suggests many were answering “Is this a good company?” instead of “Is this a good investment at today’s price?”
Translate the price into shares
Simply telling people that a share price had risen did little to change their view. In a second group, participants were told that the shares had climbed 14% since the supplier announcement. Even then, 70% expected them to do better. Some interpreted the higher price as another sign that the company was stronger.
The researchers got a different response when they showed what the price change meant in practical terms. Participants learned that $1,000 would buy 16 shares if the company kept its old supplier, but just 14 after the good news. In that group, 49% expected the shares to do better, the lowest share of participants giving that answer.
That exercise makes the trade-off concrete: a higher price buys a smaller slice of the business. It isn’t a signal to sell automatically. It’s a way to put the improved outlook alongside the cost of buying in.
Consider a simple example. If you had £1,100 to invest and the shares cost 400p before the announcement, you could buy 275 shares. At 440p, the same sum buys 250. The company’s news may be positive, but the price has reduced the number of shares your money can purchase by 25.
One rough way to think about the increase is to assume that investors still value the business at the same price/earnings (P/E) ratio. On that assumption, a 10% rise in the share price implies that investors expect profits to be about 10% higher over time. That’s only a rule of thumb: it does not establish that the company will deliver those profits or that the shares are fairly priced.
Before buying after a widely discussed announcement, ask what level of lasting improvement the current price seems to require. Then consider whether the evidence supports that expectation, and whether you have information or analysis beyond the news that has already reached the market.
Can a share keep rising after good news?
There is a case for expecting some share prices to continue adjusting after an earnings surprise. Research over several decades found that shares sometimes drifted in the direction of the news for weeks. If that pattern still held for a particular company, buyers might have gains left to capture after the first reaction.
Evidence for large British companies points to a short window. A 2024 study of FTSE 350 companies covering 2000 to 2021 found that shares with good earnings news beat the market by an average of 0.68% over the following ten trading days. After 60 days, their average outperformance was 0.71%. Almost all of the measured gain had arrived during the first two weeks, suggesting a buyer entering after four weeks would have missed most of it.
Those returns were calculated before costs. For most UK shares, stamp duty alone takes 0.5% of the amount invested, which can absorb much of a modest gain. Trading costs and the timing of a purchase also matter when assessing whether a small historical advantage would have helped an individual investor.
The findings have limits. They concern large companies, where many investors follow the business and information can be reflected in prices quickly. Evidence is thinner for smaller UK stocks, including those on AIM. A 2022 study of US shares by Charles Martineau found that by 2006 the drift had disappeared for all but the very smallest companies, while lasting longer among those firms. That result concerns a different market, so it should not be treated as a direct forecast for a UK share.
Judge the business and the price together
Fundsmith’s approach, summed up by Terry Smith, is to buy good companies, avoid overpaying and then do nothing. The survey suggests many investors stop at the first step. A strong business can still be attractive, but good news alone says little about whether its shares offer value after the market has reacted.
Investors who owned the shares when the supplier deal was announced may have benefited from the rise that followed. Someone buying four weeks later faces a different decision: the price now includes at least part of that news. Counting how many shares your money buys before and after a jump is a useful check, but it cannot settle whether the company will meet expectations.
When a recommendation rests only on a positive announcement, pause over the price. The practical question is whether the expected improvement is large and lasting enough to justify what buyers now pay. That keeps attention on both sides of the decision: the quality of the company and the value available at today’s share price.