Skip to the keys
Avihoffman

India's Stocks Are Being Called the Anti-AI Trade. Here's the Catch

Debt & Credit [email protected] (Alex Rankine) 736 reads

Indian shares posted their best week since 2021 as investors looked for markets with less AI exposure. Valuations and oil prices are the caveats worth watching.

India's Stocks Are Being Called the Anti-AI Trade. Here's the Catch

Indian shares just had a week that stood out even against a volatile backdrop. The benchmark Nifty and Sensex both climbed more than 8.5%, their strongest weekly showing since February 2021. That happened while other Asian markets fell sharply during a technology sell-off. The contrast is the interesting part. For a while, money has been moving away from the region's AI-heavy markets, and India has become the place it lands.

Why India is being called the anti-AI trade

For about two years, Indian stocks lagged while Asian investors focused on South Korea and Taiwan, markets that Manishi Raychaudhuri, writing for Reuters, describes as "tech-saturated." Those markets are built around chipmakers and hardware giants. India has no equivalent of Nvidia, Samsung or TSMC. That absence is exactly what has made it appealing to some investors in a period of AI nerves. The market has outperformed during technology sell-offs over the summer and again this autumn, which is why it's now being described as an "anti-AI" trade.

Here's the irony, though. A big part of India's anti-AI reputation comes from its outsourced IT and back-office services industry. Those firms handle work like data processing, customer support and routine administration for overseas clients. That kind of work is widely seen as "highly vulnerable" to AI tools that can take over repetitive office tasks. So the same sector that makes India look insulated from AI at the index level is the one that could feel the most pressure from it.

Not an anti-AI country, though

The stock market and the economy aren't the same thing. India may be missing AI champions in its listed companies, but it is far from opting out of the technology. More than 40% of employees report using AI tools daily, roughly double the global average. Lots of people in India are already working alongside these systems, which is a different story from a country sitting on the sidelines. My read is that the more important AI question for India is how its workforce adapts, rather than which company wins the chip race.

Indian equity indexes are still dominated by older sectors such as banking and heavy industry. Nikhil Inamdar, reporting for the BBC, notes there are "early signs" of new activity in space, defence and semiconductors. Bernstein Research sees promise in those areas too. The catch is scale. Most of these newer industries remain too small to materially shape how capital gets allocated across the market for much of this decade. Early signs are worth tracking, but they aren't yet the engine.

Who's actually holding up the market

Foreign investors have been largely on the sidelines, so something else has been keeping Indian stocks moving. That something is a fast-growing domestic investing culture. According to The Economist, the share of Indian household net financial assets held in stocks more than quintupled in the four years to March 2025. It now sits at 27% of household wealth, and the publication suggests that figure still has room to "continue to grow."

Why does that matter? When overseas money pulls back, a market with a deep base of local savers has a cushion. Regular monthly investing by households, a habit that has spread in many markets, can keep buying steady even when global sentiment turns. That's a useful feature. It also means the market's direction depends more on Indian households' appetite for risk than on global flows, which can cut both ways when sentiment shifts.

Is the price too high?

Valuation is where skeptics focus. A quick primer: the price-earnings (P/E) ratio compares a share price with the company's earnings. A forward P/E uses expected earnings over the next 12 months, so a lower number generally means investors are paying less for each rupee of expected profit. On that measure, Indian stocks sit at 18.6, far pricier than China at 9.3 or Brazil at 7.9.

Rajiv Batra of JPMorgan, speaking to CNBC, argues that the premium isn't new. Since 2007, Indian stocks have traded at an average of 1.4 times the valuations of emerging markets overall, supported by what he calls "durable earnings and a domestically driven growth engine." There's another useful data point: the Nifty is currently trading below its ten-year forward average P/E. Earnings growth now runs above 20%, which helps explain why investors are willing to pay more. A high multiple looks different when profits are growing that fast.

There are also signs that overseas investors are starting to come back. That would be a meaningful shift after the long stretch of foreign selling.

The risk that could stall the rally

India imports almost 90% of its oil. That makes the economy sensitive to crude prices in a way that matters for the stock market. A renewed spike in oil could raise costs across the economy and could quickly undo the momentum that's building. It's the kind of external shock that can change sentiment faster than earnings can respond.

So what should you take from this? The short version is that India's market has become a sort of refuge from AI-driven swings, but a refuge isn't the same as a guarantee. The trade depends on three things holding: earnings growth continuing to justify today's premium, domestic investors keeping their appetite, and oil staying in a manageable range. This is general information rather than personal investment advice, and how any of this fits a household's own goals and risk tolerance is a separate question. If you're following the story, watch the oil price, the next few rounds of earnings reports, and whether foreign money keeps returning. Those three signals will tell you more than the headline week ever could.

Source: [email protected] (Alex Rankine) · moneyweek.com

Same key